Outdoor seating: Yes
Accepts credit cards: Yes
561 Delaware Avenue
Buffalo, NY 14202
Make a reservation online
Sorry, Colter Bay Grill does not offer online reservations.
Please call (716) 882-1330 to make a reservation.
Buffalo Wings $6.95 small, $9.95 large
Try this local favorite hot, medium, or mild. Served with carrots, celery, and blue cheese.
BBQ Wings $6.95 small, $9.95 large
Our version. Wings smothered in our homemade chuck wagon bbq sauce+then grilled.
Quesadillas Veggie $5.95 Chicken $6.95
Piping hot flour tortillas filled with melted cheese, tomatoes, mushrooms, onions, peppers, and guacamole. Served with sour cream and salsa.
Potato Skins $6.95
Our spuds are served with bacon, melted cheddar, and side of sour cream.
Colter Bay Nachos $5.95
Toasted chips with melted cheddar and jack cheeses, topped with jalapeño peppers. Salsa and sour cream join the nachos.
Elk Island Nachos $9.95
The King of Nachos! Toasted chips covered with black beans, seasoned ground beef. Then topped off with guacamole, jalapeño peppers, melted jack/cheddar cheeses. Served with sour cream and salsa.
Humus & Grilled Pita $6.75
Homemade humus with grilled pita and chopped tomatoes.
Spinach Dip $6.95
Spinach and artichoke combination dip. Served with sliced pita bread.
Salads and Soups
Chuckwagon $1.95 cup $2.95 bowl
Our soup of the day.
John Colter’s Hearty Soup $1.95 cup $2.95bowl
A hearty gumbo style soup with sausage, chicken, rice, and assorted veggies.
French Onion Soup $3.95 bowl
Basic Salad $6.25
A great combination of crisp greens, fresh veggies, and shredded jack/cheddar cheese.
Colter Bay Greens $7.25
A meal in itself! Fresh greens mixed with turkey, red onion, avocado, tomato, cucumbers, sprouts, mushrooms, jack/cheddar cheese, topped with croutons.
Targhee Salad $7.95
A beautiful national forest on the western side of the Tetons. Fresh greens topped with grilled chicken, chopped artichoke hearts, tomatoes, grated parmesan cheese and capped with sprouts.
Summit Salad $7.95
A delightful combo of fresh greens, marinated beef, cucumbers & tomatoes, together with feta cheese and olives. Seasoned oregano, oil, and vinegar.
Old West Salad $8.95
An old Wyoming favorite. Marinated strips of beef and chicken are joined with grilled onion, tomato, cucumber, and grated cheese over fresh greens.
Caesar Salad $6.25
Grilled Chicken Caesar $7.95
Our Caesar topped with marinated strips of grilled chicken.
*Dinner salad available with another menu item – $1.95
*Crumbled blue cheese or feta cheese – $1.00
Honey Dijon, Parmesan Peppercorn, Ranch, Blue Cheese, Tomato Basil Vinaigrette, Low-cal Italian, Oil & Vinegar, plus seasonal and featured.
Traditional Pizza $6.75 Cheese and pepperoni with red sauce.
Veggie Pizza $6.95 Pizza topped with a variety of veggies.
Cowboy Pizza $7.95 Grilled chicken, barbecue sauce, shredded cheddar, and tomatoes
Daily Pizza feature – Our kitchen staff features a unique pizza daily. Ask your server or check out the blackboard for today’s feature.
Glacier Club $7.50
A triple-decker with turkey, bacon, tomato, cheese, and lettuce on your choice of bread.
Sliced turkey breast, avocado, jack cheese, sliced tomato served with dill spread or mayo.
Monte Cristo $6.95
A popular sandwich throughout the Rockies and Wyoming. Slices of turkey, ham, and swiss cheese on bread, then dipped in an egg batter and grilled golden brown.
Tuna Melt $6.95
Tuna salad on rye bread with cheddar and tomato, then grilled and topped with sprouts.
Turkey Grill $6.95
Turkey, jack cheese, tomato, bacon, and thousand island dressing, then grilled together.
John Colter $7.25
The famous explorer which Colter Bay is named after and this great sandwich! Roast beef with green peppers, mushrooms, onions, tomato, and provolone, grilled together.
A Colter favorite! Tomato, onion, avocado, cucumber, sprouts, jack/cheddar cheese with a dill spread on your choice of bread.
Grilled Veggie Sandwich $6.95
Tomato, zucchini, and red onion marinated in olive oil and fresh herbs, then grilled. Served on a roll with pesto and mozzarella.
Old Faithful $6.75
Pick an item from each section to create your favorite sandwich:
A – turkey, roast beef, or ham
B – pick two: lettuce, tomato, avocado, onion, American cheese, jack, swiss, or cheddar cheese
C- your favorite bread
*Extra items – $0.95
SIDES: Side salad, fries, chips, or daily pasta salad.
BREADS: Sourdough, Whole Grain Wheat, Rye, Pita, Foccacia, White, or Roll.
*All sandwiches served with choice of bread and side.
*All of our sandwich selections may be made into a wrap or try one our house creations.
Cajun Turkey $6.95 Turkey, peppers, onions, guacamole, and cheddar all wrapped in a tortilla.
Valley Wrap $6.25 Hummus and grilled veggies in a tortilla.
Grand Teton Wrap $7.95 Grilled steak, mushrooms, and, provolone, together in a tortilla.
Jerk Chicken Wrap $6.95 Spicy shredded jerk chicken, jack and cheddar, onion, and tomatoes.
Burgers and Chicken
*All our 9oz burgers are made fresh daily with the finest ground beef and grilled to perfection. All our chicken sandwiches are 6oz skinless breasts & grilled tender and moist. All items with choice of side.
Colter Bay Burger $7.50 Overflowing with flavor-served with cheddar, red onion, mushrooms, and bacon.
Wyoming Burger $7.25 Hearty and zesty, served with guacamole, cheddar, salsa, and jalapeno peppers.
Frontiersman $7.50 An adventure in burgers! A burger topped with our homemade bbq sauce, Cajun spices, cheddar, bacon, onion, lettuce, and tomato packed together on a roll.
Jackson Hole plain – $6.75, w/cheese – $6.95
It doesn’t get any more authentic than this burger! Served with lettuce and tomato.
Wyoming Chicken $7.25 Just like our Wyoming burger. Grilled chicken topped with guacamole, grated cheddar, salsa, diced jalapeno peppers on a roll.
Colter Bay Chicken $7.50 Our house favorite! Grilled chicken smothered in our bbq sauce, cheddar, and bacon.
Teton Chicken $7.50 Grilled chicken topped with bacon, cheese, lettuce, and tomato on a roll.
Cajun Chicken $6.95 Grilled chicken in cajun spices topped with grilled onions and peppers.
Jenny Lake Chicken $7.50 A beautiful lake at the base of the Tetons Mts. This sandwich is topped with spinach, mushrooms, and swiss cheese.
Fish Fry Friday
*Join us for a Traditional Buffalo Fish Fry every Friday. Served for lunch or dinner.
Traditional Fish Fry $7.95 Fried or broiled haddock, fries, coleslaw, and lemon wedge.
Fried Fish Sandwich $6.75 Lightly fried haddock on a roll with choice of side.
View Larger Map