Details
Price: $$
Attire: Casual
Outdoor seating: Yes
Delivery: No
Accepts credit cards: Yes
Location
561 Delaware Avenue
Buffalo, NY 14202
(716) 882-1330
www.colterbaygrill.com
Make a reservation online
Sorry, Colter Bay Grill does not offer online reservations.
Please call (716) 882-1330 to make a reservation.
Menu
Openers
Buffalo Wings $6.95 small, $9.95 large
Try this local favorite hot, medium, or mild. Served with carrots, celery, and blue cheese.BBQ Wings $6.95 small, $9.95 large
Our version. Wings smothered in our homemade chuck wagon bbq sauce+then grilled.Quesadillas Veggie $5.95 Chicken $6.95
Piping hot flour tortillas filled with melted cheese, tomatoes, mushrooms, onions, peppers, and guacamole. Served with sour cream and salsa.Potato Skins $6.95
Our spuds are served with bacon, melted cheddar, and side of sour cream.Colter Bay Nachos $5.95
Toasted chips with melted cheddar and jack cheeses, topped with jalapeño peppers. Salsa and sour cream join the nachos.Elk Island Nachos $9.95
The King of Nachos! Toasted chips covered with black beans, seasoned ground beef. Then topped off with guacamole, jalapeño peppers, melted jack/cheddar cheeses. Served with sour cream and salsa.Humus & Grilled Pita $6.75
Homemade humus with grilled pita and chopped tomatoes.Spinach Dip $6.95
Spinach and artichoke combination dip. Served with sliced pita bread.Salads and Soups
Chuckwagon $1.95 cup $2.95 bowl
Our soup of the day.John Colter’s Hearty Soup $1.95 cup $2.95bowl
A hearty gumbo style soup with sausage, chicken, rice, and assorted veggies.French Onion Soup $3.95 bowl
Basic Salad $6.25
A great combination of crisp greens, fresh veggies, and shredded jack/cheddar cheese.Colter Bay Greens $7.25
A meal in itself! Fresh greens mixed with turkey, red onion, avocado, tomato, cucumbers, sprouts, mushrooms, jack/cheddar cheese, topped with croutons.Targhee Salad $7.95
A beautiful national forest on the western side of the Tetons. Fresh greens topped with grilled chicken, chopped artichoke hearts, tomatoes, grated parmesan cheese and capped with sprouts.Summit Salad $7.95
A delightful combo of fresh greens, marinated beef, cucumbers & tomatoes, together with feta cheese and olives. Seasoned oregano, oil, and vinegar.Old West Salad $8.95
An old Wyoming favorite. Marinated strips of beef and chicken are joined with grilled onion, tomato, cucumber, and grated cheese over fresh greens.Caesar Salad $6.25
Grilled Chicken Caesar $7.95
Our Caesar topped with marinated strips of grilled chicken.*Dinner salad available with another menu item – $1.95
*Crumbled blue cheese or feta cheese – $1.00Salad Dressings
Honey Dijon, Parmesan Peppercorn, Ranch, Blue Cheese, Tomato Basil Vinaigrette, Low-cal Italian, Oil & Vinegar, plus seasonal and featured.Pizza
Traditional Pizza $6.75 Cheese and pepperoni with red sauce.
Veggie Pizza $6.95 Pizza topped with a variety of veggies.
Cowboy Pizza $7.95 Grilled chicken, barbecue sauce, shredded cheddar, and tomatoes
Daily Pizza feature – Our kitchen staff features a unique pizza daily. Ask your server or check out the blackboard for today’s feature.
Hearty Sandwiches
Glacier Club $7.50
A triple-decker with turkey, bacon, tomato, cheese, and lettuce on your choice of bread.Yellowstone $6.95
Sliced turkey breast, avocado, jack cheese, sliced tomato served with dill spread or mayo.Monte Cristo $6.95
A popular sandwich throughout the Rockies and Wyoming. Slices of turkey, ham, and swiss cheese on bread, then dipped in an egg batter and grilled golden brown.Tuna Melt $6.95
Tuna salad on rye bread with cheddar and tomato, then grilled and topped with sprouts.Turkey Grill $6.95
Turkey, jack cheese, tomato, bacon, and thousand island dressing, then grilled together.John Colter $7.25
The famous explorer which Colter Bay is named after and this great sandwich! Roast beef with green peppers, mushrooms, onions, tomato, and provolone, grilled together.Teewinot $6.25
A Colter favorite! Tomato, onion, avocado, cucumber, sprouts, jack/cheddar cheese with a dill spread on your choice of bread.Grilled Veggie Sandwich $6.95
Tomato, zucchini, and red onion marinated in olive oil and fresh herbs, then grilled. Served on a roll with pesto and mozzarella.Old Faithful $6.75
Pick an item from each section to create your favorite sandwich:
A – turkey, roast beef, or ham
B – pick two: lettuce, tomato, avocado, onion, American cheese, jack, swiss, or cheddar cheese
C- your favorite bread
*Extra items – $0.95SIDES: Side salad, fries, chips, or daily pasta salad.
BREADS: Sourdough, Whole Grain Wheat, Rye, Pita, Foccacia, White, or Roll.*All sandwiches served with choice of bread and side.
Wraps
*All of our sandwich selections may be made into a wrap or try one our house creations.
Cajun Turkey $6.95 Turkey, peppers, onions, guacamole, and cheddar all wrapped in a tortilla.
Valley Wrap $6.25 Hummus and grilled veggies in a tortilla.
Grand Teton Wrap $7.95 Grilled steak, mushrooms, and, provolone, together in a tortilla.
Jerk Chicken Wrap $6.95 Spicy shredded jerk chicken, jack and cheddar, onion, and tomatoes.
Burgers and Chicken
*All our 9oz burgers are made fresh daily with the finest ground beef and grilled to perfection. All our chicken sandwiches are 6oz skinless breasts & grilled tender and moist. All items with choice of side.
Colter Bay Burger $7.50 Overflowing with flavor-served with cheddar, red onion, mushrooms, and bacon.
Wyoming Burger $7.25 Hearty and zesty, served with guacamole, cheddar, salsa, and jalapeno peppers.
Frontiersman $7.50 An adventure in burgers! A burger topped with our homemade bbq sauce, Cajun spices, cheddar, bacon, onion, lettuce, and tomato packed together on a roll.
Jackson Hole plain – $6.75, w/cheese – $6.95
It doesn’t get any more authentic than this burger! Served with lettuce and tomato.Wyoming Chicken $7.25 Just like our Wyoming burger. Grilled chicken topped with guacamole, grated cheddar, salsa, diced jalapeno peppers on a roll.
Colter Bay Chicken $7.50 Our house favorite! Grilled chicken smothered in our bbq sauce, cheddar, and bacon.
Teton Chicken $7.50 Grilled chicken topped with bacon, cheese, lettuce, and tomato on a roll.
Cajun Chicken $6.95 Grilled chicken in cajun spices topped with grilled onions and peppers.
Jenny Lake Chicken $7.50 A beautiful lake at the base of the Tetons Mts. This sandwich is topped with spinach, mushrooms, and swiss cheese.
Fish Fry Friday
*Join us for a Traditional Buffalo Fish Fry every Friday. Served for lunch or dinner.
Traditional Fish Fry $7.95 Fried or broiled haddock, fries, coleslaw, and lemon wedge.
Fried Fish Sandwich $6.75 Lightly fried haddock on a roll with choice of side.
Directions
View Larger Map
1 Review for "Colter Bay Grill"
enjoyed my colter bay chicken, crispy bacon but light on the cheddar – scimpy on this. The local beer was dissapointing “holy moses” so watery. I had had a saranac from the tap earlier & it was robust, nice bite to it. We ate in the back section but talking was v. difficult as the music was just too damn loud. May hesitate to eat there again because of this. Not a weekend loud night we were there, it was a Thursday.
Review Now!